Skip to main content

Water Quality for Coffee: The Most Important Ingredient

6 min read

Water Quality for Coffee

Coffee is 98% water. Water quality dramatically affects extraction, flavor, and machine longevity. Great beans with bad water = mediocre coffee.

Why Water Matters

Water’s Role in Coffee

Extraction: Water dissolves flavor compounds from coffee grounds. Mineral content affects extraction efficiency.

Flavor: Water contributes its own taste. Chlorine, metals, and contaminants ruin coffee flavor.

Equipment: Hard water causes scale buildup. Too soft water causes corrosion.

Ideal Water Composition

TDS (Total Dissolved Solids)

What It Is: Total minerals and substances in water (measured in ppm or mg/L).

Ideal Range:

  • SCA Standard: 75-250 ppm
  • Optimal: 100-150 ppm
  • Too low (<50 ppm): Under-extraction, flat taste
  • Too high (>250 ppm): Over-extraction, equipment scale

Testing: Use TDS meter ($15-30 on Amazon).

Key Minerals

Calcium (Ca²⁺):

  • Enhances extraction
  • Adds body and mouthfeel
  • Ideal: 50-75 ppm
  • Too much: Scale buildup

Magnesium (Mg²⁺):

  • Extracts fruity, acidic notes
  • Enhances brightness
  • Ideal: 10-30 ppm
  • Too much: Bitter over-extraction

Bicarbonate (HCO₃⁻):

  • Buffers acidity
  • Too much: Chalky, flat taste
  • Too little: Overly acidic
  • Ideal: 40-75 ppm

Sodium (Na⁺):

  • Can enhance flavor at low levels
  • Ideal: <10 ppm
  • Too much: Salty taste, equipment damage

pH Level

Ideal Range: 6.5-7.5 (neutral to slightly acidic)

Too Low (<6.5): Corrosive to equipment, overly bright coffee

Too High (>7.5): Chalky taste, flat coffee

Common Water Problems

Tap Water Issues

Chlorine:

  • Added for sanitation
  • Tastes medicinal, ruins coffee
  • Fix: Carbon filter, let water sit overnight

Chloramine:

  • Similar to chlorine but stronger
  • Doesn’t evaporate
  • Fix: Carbon filter (higher-end) or Third Wave Water

Heavy Metals:

  • Lead, copper from old pipes
  • Health risk + off-flavors
  • Fix: Reverse osmosis filtration

Hard Water (High Mineral Content):

  • Causes scale buildup in machines
  • Can over-extract coffee
  • Fix: Water softener, remineralization

Soft Water (Low Mineral Content):

  • Under-extracts coffee
  • Flat, dull taste
  • Can corrode equipment
  • Fix: Add minerals (Third Wave Water, custom recipe)

Distilled/RO Water Issues

Problem: Zero minerals = zero extraction efficiency.

Taste: Flat, sour, thin, under-extracted.

Fix: Remineralize with mineral packets or DIY recipe.

Water Solutions

Carbon Filters (Basic)

What They Do: Remove chlorine, some contaminants, improve taste.

Examples:

  • Brita pitcher ($25)
  • Inline carbon filters ($30-50)
  • Faucet filters ($20)

Pros:

  • Cheap and easy
  • Removes chlorine
  • Improves taste

Cons:

  • Doesn’t adjust mineral content
  • Doesn’t remove everything

Best For: Decent tap water that just needs chlorine removal.

Reverse Osmosis (RO) Filtration

What It Does: Removes 95-99% of all minerals and contaminants.

Cost: $150-500 for under-sink system

Pros:

  • Cleanest water possible
  • Removes everything harmful
  • Great starting point

Cons:

  • Requires remineralization for coffee
  • Wastes water (3-4 gallons per 1 gallon produced)
  • Installation required

Best For: Bad tap water + DIY remineralization.

Bottled Water

Best Brands for Coffee:

  • Crystal Geyser: 70-80 ppm TDS (good balance)
  • Volvic: Balanced minerals
  • Fiji: Good mineral profile

Avoid:

  • Distilled water (0 TDS)
  • High mineral content (Evian, San Pellegrino)
  • Purified water without minerals

Pros:

  • Consistent results
  • No equipment needed
  • Travel-friendly

Cons:

  • Expensive long-term
  • Environmental impact (plastic)
  • Limited mineral control

Third Wave Water

What It Is: Mineral packets you add to distilled or RO water.

Cost: $15 for 12 packets (makes 12 gallons)

How It Works:

  1. Buy distilled water or use RO system
  2. Add one packet per gallon
  3. Wait 5 minutes for minerals to dissolve

Pros:

  • Perfect mineral balance for coffee
  • Consistent results
  • No equipment needed
  • SCA-compliant

Cons:

  • Ongoing cost ($1.25 per gallon)
  • Requires distilled/RO water

Best For: Consistent, competition-grade water without DIY effort.

BWT Water Filter Pitcher

What It Is: Pitcher that filters AND remineralizes specifically for coffee.

Cost: $40-50 for pitcher

Pros:

  • Designed for coffee
  • Adds magnesium
  • Affordable
  • Easy to use

Cons:

  • Filter replacement costs
  • Limited capacity

Best For: Home brewers wanting easy, optimized water.

DIY Water Recipes

The Barista Hustle Recipe

For 1 Liter:

  • 1 liter distilled water
  • 0.06g (60mg) Epsom salt (magnesium sulfate)
  • 0.04g (40mg) baking soda (sodium bicarbonate)

Result: ~100 ppm TDS, balanced minerals

Cost: ~$0.05 per liter

The Rao/Perger Recipe

For 1 Gallon:

  • 1 gallon distilled water
  • 1.68g Epsom salt (magnesium sulfate)
  • 1.12g baking soda (sodium bicarbonate)

Result: SCA-compliant, competition water

Simple Magnesium Water

For 1 Liter:

  • 1 liter distilled water
  • 0.08g (80mg) Epsom salt

Result: Low TDS, magnesium-forward extraction (bright, fruity)

DIY Water Tips

Equipment Needed:

  • Digital scale (0.01g precision)
  • Distilled water
  • Epsom salt (pharmacy or grocery store)
  • Baking soda (grocery store)
  • Storage container

Mixing:

  1. Measure ingredients precisely
  2. Add to distilled water
  3. Shake well until dissolved
  4. Store in sealed container

Shelf Life: Lasts indefinitely if stored properly (sealed container).

Water for Different Brewing Methods

Espresso

Requirements:

  • Lower mineral content (50-100 ppm)
  • Avoid scale buildup in expensive machines
  • Magnesium for extraction

Best Option: RO + remineralization or Third Wave Water

Why: Espresso machines are sensitive to scale. Hard water will ruin them.

Pour Over / Drip

Requirements:

  • Moderate minerals (100-150 ppm)
  • Balanced extraction
  • Chlorine-free

Best Option: Carbon-filtered tap water or bottled water (Crystal Geyser)

Why: More forgiving than espresso, but water still matters.

Cold Brew

Requirements:

  • Clean water
  • Lower mineral content OK (long extraction time compensates)

Best Option: Carbon-filtered tap or any clean water

Why: 12-24 hour extraction is very forgiving.

French Press

Requirements:

  • Moderate to high minerals (100-150 ppm)
  • Fuller extraction

Best Option: Carbon-filtered tap with moderate hardness

Why: Immersion brewing extracts fully regardless of mineral content.

Testing Your Water

TDS Meter

Cost: $15-30 What It Measures: Total dissolved solids (ppm) How: Dip in water, instant reading

Interpreting Results:

  • <50 ppm: Too soft, remineralize
  • 50-75 ppm: Good for espresso
  • 100-150 ppm: Ideal for coffee
  • 150-250 ppm: Acceptable

  • 250 ppm: Too hard, filter needed

Test Strips

Cost: $10-20 for 50 strips What They Measure: pH, hardness, chlorine, metals How: Dip strip, compare colors to chart

Professional Water Test

Cost: $30-100 What It Measures: Complete mineral breakdown, contaminants Where: Mail-in lab testing

When Needed: Serious espresso setup, recurring problems, bad-tasting tap water.

Equipment Scale Prevention

Descaling

Why: Hard water leaves mineral deposits (scale) that clog and damage machines.

How Often:

  • Hard water (>150 ppm): Monthly
  • Moderate water (100-150 ppm): Quarterly
  • Soft/RO water (<100 ppm): Rarely needed

Products:

  • Urnex Dezcal ($15)
  • Citric acid (cheap, works well)
  • Commercial descaling solutions

Process:

  1. Fill reservoir with descaling solution
  2. Run through machine without coffee
  3. Run 2-3 cycles with clean water to rinse

Scale Prevention

Best Practices:

  • Use low-TDS water (<100 ppm for espresso)
  • Descale regularly
  • Empty machine reservoir weekly
  • Use filtered or remineralized water

Water Storage

Storage Container

Best: Glass or stainless steel (won’t leach flavors)

Avoid: Plastic (can leach chemicals over time)

Shelf Life

Distilled/RO Water: Indefinite if sealed

Remineralized Water: Indefinite if sealed

Filtered Tap Water: Use within 1 week (bacteria can grow)

Common Water Mistakes

Mistake 1: Using Distilled Water Without Remineralizing

Problem: Under-extraction, sour, thin coffee.

Fix: Add minerals (Third Wave Water, DIY recipe).

Mistake 2: Ignoring Water for Espresso

Problem: Scale buildup ruins expensive machines.

Fix: Use low-TDS water (RO + remineralization).

Mistake 3: Assuming Bottled Water Is Good

Problem: Many bottled waters have wrong mineral balance.

Fix: Test TDS, use known-good brands (Crystal Geyser).

Mistake 4: Over-Complicating Water

Problem: Obsessing over water while using stale, low-quality beans.

Fix: Good water matters, but fresh beans matter more. Optimize both.

Takeaway

Water is 98% of coffee: It’s the most important ingredient after the beans.

Start simple:

  • Good tap water + carbon filter = 80% of the way there
  • Avoid chlorine and high minerals
  • Test with TDS meter ($15)

Level up:

  • Third Wave Water (easy, consistent)
  • RO + remineralization (best control)
  • DIY recipes (cheapest long-term)

For espresso: Water quality is critical. Use low-TDS, remineralized water to protect your machine.

For everything else: Carbon-filtered tap water works for most people.

Next Steps